[Yr7-10it] Re : .. Programming for all levels

[Costello, Rob R]

Following all these programming discussions with interest 

Here's a thought for you... 

How did you all learn programming? 

What role did formal school have, if any? 

How much personal time? 

I remember reading something David Perkins said - that in his
observations - circa 1985 - none of the budding student programmers he
observed had arrived at any competence without a huge personal
investment of time  

I've gone into bat for Logo in school at times - along the lines of
thinking "where is the DNA for a programming mindset for students,
unless we offer something parallel to the BASIC language I learnt".  

But maybe its the lack of a "BASIC" that is the real problem - a generic
(and fairly common) "Beginners All Purpose Symbolic Instruction Code" on
most computers  - and I guess that's whats under discussion in all these
discussions - whats the best "BASIC" these days.  
Maybe we just need to put a few good tools in their hands and start them
off - Alice, Scratch, Gamemaker, Squeak - whatever. 

Let those who like it, run with it 

Maybe not Javascript, C#, Java, Actionscript etc 

At least, not at first 

Harder to get to an independent / creative level there, I reckon 

(In spite of the prevalence of Javascript on the web, I think its pretty
hard to deeply "get", without an OOP background) 

I like the visual drag and drop of GameMaker - although it's a pity it
doesn't show the corresponding code when you drag in an "icon" - and I
feel the pure coding side of GM is still quite tricky, a "curly bracket"
language,  with events, object level scope etc - compared to the old
procedural BASIC, its not easy.  
I know kids can dabble in a bit of code in GM, on top of their visual
stuff, which is nice - but again how much are they "getting" in a
transferable way.  I love its visual productivity - pity it doesn't show
the code of their visual efforts - a little like recording a visual
basic macro. 

 I reckon VB is ok - if you can avoid the temptation to go GUI too early
- but the language has got so cluttered its not as much of a beginners
sand pit (.net even less so) 

Anyway  

How did you all learn programming? 

Cheers 

Rob  


Important - This email and any attachments may be confidential. If received in error, please contact us and delete all copies. Before opening or using attachments check them for viruses and defects. Regardless of any loss, damage or consequence, whether caused by the negligence of the sender or not, resulting directly or indirectly from the use of any attached files our liability is limited to resupplying any affected attachments. Any representations or opinions expressed are those of the individual sender, and not necessarily those of the Department of Education and Early Childhood Development.